When Cheryl posts a new lot of queries I always feel a little guilty. In the average week I don’t request any books. At my current rate I review about one book a month (50 since 2006), and about half of those are books I bought for myself. On one hand I feel guilty for the wasted effort that authors put into writing the queries, on the other hand I figure it is good practice and better than having actual unwanted copies of the book floating around.
In some ways it is even worse if I do like the look of a book. I have a job, books to write, blogs to run and a to-be-read pile that doubles as a (somewhat lumpy) coffee table. There is just no way in the world that there is enough time to read all the intriguing self-published books that we are offered. Which, I guess, as problems go—isn’t a bad one. It is not just the volume of self-published books that has increased over the years but also the diversity and the quality.
In the end all I can promise is that I read every query and I seriously consider requesting the book, as—I am sure—do Chris and Cheryl. If your query was unsuccessful this is almost certainly down to a matter of genre, or taste, or sheer lack of time. And if you know of anyone who would like to join our reviewing team, send them along. There is no shortage of books for them!
In some ways it is even worse if I do like the look of a book. I have a job, books to write, blogs to run and a to-be-read pile that doubles as a (somewhat lumpy) coffee table. There is just no way in the world that there is enough time to read all the intriguing self-published books that we are offered. Which, I guess, as problems go—isn’t a bad one. It is not just the volume of self-published books that has increased over the years but also the diversity and the quality.
In the end all I can promise is that I read every query and I seriously consider requesting the book, as—I am sure—do Chris and Cheryl. If your query was unsuccessful this is almost certainly down to a matter of genre, or taste, or sheer lack of time. And if you know of anyone who would like to join our reviewing team, send them along. There is no shortage of books for them!
Comments
I go through the queries and if they aren't well written I generally pass. If the query doesn't include a link to a preview, I pass. And if I read the preview and there are grammatical issues, again, I pass, but mostly, I pass on specific genres and or styles of writing and that is purely a taste thing, nothing more.
We are but a few to do a job for many, not to mention we all have day jobs, our own writing careers, and other hobbies and activities as well, including our own personal reading. I average about one SP book a month, and that's mostly because it takes me forever to write a nice, long well-thought-out review. I could rush and do a one-liner, but who would benefit from that?
When I accept a book for review, I let the author know that it can take upwards of 10+ weeks to get a review and that I will keep them posted when I start reading the book. I haven't had a complaint yet, and I don't accept more than I can handle, so that means I have to pass on some for no other reason than I am booked solid. I prefer no more than 10 in my queue at any one time.
-Shannon
LLBR
With indie gatekeepers like us, we are looking for quality too, but I think we are looking for new voices and new ideas, new thoughts more so than just what sells.
So yes, I gatekeep a little, but only when it comes to a story being grammatically and structurally well written. You gotta learn the language and the theory. That's my only real sticking point. For me, I am looking for style and substance. Nothing wrong with gatekeeping by that mantra.
Fill free to suggest people to query us for the ones you turn down. We have one reviewer who only does YA.
Thanks,
Shannon